Review: Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda MX-5

Review: Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda MX-5
Review: Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda MX-5

The Fiat 124 Spider has already been pitted against Mazda MX-5 many times on the road, but how do they compare on the track? We decided to find out, on the tight, tenacious Blyton Park racetrack in Lincolnshire. If ever a place were made for a playful little roadster, it’s this.

OK, we didn’t test like with like. The 124 Spider was a 138bhp turbocharged 1.4-litre, whereas the MX-5 was a 2.0-litre Sport Recaro edition complete with 158bhp, Bilstein dampers and limited-slip differential.

This is why, against the clock, the MX-5 was 2.5 seconds faster per lap. The Fiat is 20bhp down and it feels like more, as the Mazda is quite the performer.

And the Mazda’s clear advantage didn’t end there. It’s hardly a Caterham Seven, but it still has excellent body control, can be steered on the throttle and pointed accurately into corners, while body control is excellent.

The Fiat, in comparison, is softer and soggier. It rolls more in corners and the nose dives under braking. Really, despite being derived directly from the Mazda, it’s a different car entirely, aimed at a different market.

This is actually good news though. We were fearful the Fiat would feel a facsimile of the Mazda, but it’s nothing of the sort. Both have their own characters – it’s just that in these circumstances, the Mazda’s character is better-suited to the conditions.

Fiat has an answer though. The Abarth version of the 124 Spider is on the way which give the sporty MX-5 a much sterner challenge. Track test take two? Watch this space.

Buying used: Fiat 500 vs Skoda Citigo

These cars are hot in the city but should you go for fashion or common sense?If you’re thinking of a cool, stylish, retro city car you’re

Renault Clio Renault Sport 220 Trophy review

I had to double take when I looked at the spec sheet for the Renault Clio which arrived for testing last month. 217bhp in a B-segment hatch

Peugeot 508 review: a pleasing balancing act

The D-segment gains another sensible hatchbackThere’s a new Peugeot conservative saloon/fastback. Do you care? Jean-Philippe Imparato,

Aston Martin Vantage vs Porsche 911 vs McLaren 540C sports car triple test

Testing a lottery winner’s dream garage, back-to-backHow do you make a sportscar even more appealing? Make it a super sportscar. First